CloudMyLab Blog | Network Lab Guides, Tutorials & Automation Tips

Which Network Emulation Software Fits Application Testing?

Written by Abhimanyu Saharan | May 1, 2024, 3:55:42 AM

If your application passes every test in the lab and then times out for users on a branch office link, the lab was too kind to it. Test labs usually sit on a fast, clean network next to the servers. Real users sit behind WAN links, VPNs, firewalls and routing changes. Emulation closes that gap by putting the network your application will actually face into the test.

The catch is that "network emulation software" covers three different kinds of tool, and they test different things. Which one you need depends on the failure you are trying to catch.

Table of contents:

What is network emulation for application testing?

It means running your application across a virtual network that behaves like the real one, so you can see how it handles the conditions users will meet. Depending on the tool, that network either adds conditions to a link (delay, jitter, packet loss, limited bandwidth) or rebuilds the actual devices in the path (routers, switches, firewalls running real vendor software).

Simulation is a different thing. A simulator models network behavior and does not run real device software, so it suits research, teaching and capacity planning more than application testing. Apposite, which makes hardware emulators, explains the difference in its guide to network emulation vs simulation.

The three kinds of network emulation software at a glance

  Impairment emulators Topology emulators Network simulators
What it does Adds delay, jitter, loss and bandwidth limits to traffic on a link Runs real router, switch and firewall images in a virtual topology Models network behavior instead of running real device software
Examples Software: Linux tc netem, Toxiproxy (TCP-level faults between services). Hardware: Keysight, Spirent, Apposite appliances EVE-NG, GNS3, Cisco Modeling Labs, Containerlab ns-3, Cisco Packet Tracer
Runs your application? Yes, through the impaired link Yes, across the emulated network Not usually
Runs real vendor software? No Yes No
Best for Timeouts, retries, streaming and voice quality on poor links Failover logic, routing changes, firewall rules, multi-vendor paths Research, teaching, large-scale design modeling (ns-3)
Not built for Rebuilding the device path or vendor features Precise line-rate traffic shaping Testing real applications or configurations

Many QA programs end up with two of these: an impairment tool to make the network bad, and a device-level emulator to make the network real. The topology layer is the one that takes servers, images and upkeep. CloudMyLab hosts that layer for you, with GNS3, EVE-NG and Cisco Modeling Labs 2.0 managed by certified engineers on isolated, secure testing infrastructure, so your team's time goes into test cases.

Which kind does your application test need?

Begin with the failure you want to catch.

If your question is how the application behaves when the network is slow or lossy, you need an impairment emulator. Timeout values, retry logic, session recovery, video bitrate adaptation and voice quality all fail under delay, jitter and loss, and an impairment tool lets you dial those conditions in and repeat them exactly. Software tools are enough for functional testing: Linux tc netem shapes delay, jitter and loss on a link, and Toxiproxy injects latency and connection faults on TCP traffic between services. When you need precise, line-rate impairment at high throughput, a hardware appliance from Keysight, Spirent or Apposite is the right tool; Keysight describes its network emulator hardware for that job.

If your question is what happens to the application when the network itself changes, you need to emulate the topology. A link fails and routing converges onto a backup path. A firewall policy changes. An SD-WAN edge picks a different transport. A load balancer pool drains. These events depend on how real devices behave, and EVE-NG, GNS3, Cisco Modeling Labs or Containerlab run the real vendor software that produces that behavior, so your application meets the same kinds of events it would meet in production: routing reconvergence, a policy change, a path switch. The result is production-representative for control-plane and configuration behavior, but convergence and failover timing can differ from hardware, and it does not reproduce hardware forwarding performance.

If your question is how the design behaves at a scale you cannot build, such as thousands of nodes, a simulator is the honest answer. It will not tell you how your application code behaves, but it can tell you where a design runs out of room.

For changes to the network rather than the application, the same topology approach applies. Our guide to using a managed virtual network lab for safer changes walks through that workflow step by step.

How do you combine impairment and topology emulation?

You do not have to choose one. The most useful application test environments put both in the same lab.

The simplest pattern is to build the network path in EVE-NG, GNS3 or Cisco Modeling Labs and place an impairment point inside it. A small Linux node running tc netem, placed between the branch segment and the WAN in your topology, lets you add delay and loss on that one link while the routers, firewalls and servers around it run real software. Your application then crosses a network that is both realistic in its devices and degraded in its conditions.

For larger programs, the emulated topology holds the multi-vendor network and a hardware impairment or traffic appliance connects to it for the performance runs. The emulated lab answers whether the application and the network work together; the appliance answers how they perform under measured load. Our article on when an emulated lab beats a hardware lab explains which tests belong on which side of that split.

Automation makes either pattern repeatable. Tools such as Ansible and Python with Netmiko can build the topology, apply the impairment profile, run the test suite and tear it down, so each release is tested against the same network conditions instead of whatever the lab looked like that week.

What makes topology emulation hard to run in-house?

Impairment tools are light. Device-level emulators are not, and this is the layer that needs real servers.

Most router, firewall or switch images run as virtual machines with their own memory and CPU appetite, so a realistic path with a few vendors quickly outgrows a laptop or a spare server. The emulator also needs hardware virtualization exposed to it; running it inside another virtual machine can slow images down or stop them from booting. Then there are the images themselves. Every vendor image has to be sourced, licensed, uploaded and kept current, and that work lands on whoever owns the lab.

Shared access is the last problem. A QA team, the developers who need to reproduce a bug and the network engineers who own the real configuration all need the same lab, with their own access and without breaking each other's tests. A single self-hosted server rarely makes that easy.

Where does CloudMyLab fit?

CloudMyLab is an IaaS provider that runs the topology layer for you. You get hosted GNS3, EVE-NG or Cisco Modeling Labs 2.0 on virtual machines or bare metal servers, managed by certified engineers, with 24/7/365 priority support. We can also host Containerlab labs for you. The platform is technology and vendor agnostic, and you can upload and install your own images (where licensing allows), so you can test against the same vendor software your production network runs. Vendor image licenses stay your responsibility, as with any self-hosted lab. For timing-sensitive QA runs, choose bare metal.

There is no long-term contract, and you can try hosted EVE-NG Pro or Cisco Modeling Labs 2.0 with a 24-hour trial before you commit. Impairment tools work alongside the hosted lab in the patterns above, whether that is a Linux impairment node inside the topology or your existing appliance.

If you test networking products rather than applications, such as vendor firmware or telecom equipment, our guide to emulated labs for telecom and equipment QA teams covers that program in more depth. For a wider comparison of hosted platforms, see the hosted emulation platforms compared side by side.

Choosing the right network emulation software

Pick by the failure you need to catch. Use an impairment emulator when the question is how your application copes with a bad network, a topology emulator when the question is how it copes with a changing one, and a simulator only when you need scale that nothing else can build. Most application test programs need the first two together.

If you want the topology layer without building and maintaining the servers behind it, explore CloudMyLab's hosted emulators or start a 24-hour trial of hosted EVE-NG Pro or Cisco Modeling Labs 2.0.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best network emulation software for performance testing applications?

It depends on what you are testing. For timeouts, retries and quality under poor network conditions, an impairment emulator is the right choice: Linux tc netem or Toxiproxy (for TCP-level faults) for functional tests, or a Keysight, Spirent or Apposite appliance for precise line-rate impairment. For failover, routing and multi-vendor path behavior, a topology emulator such as EVE-NG, GNS3, Cisco Modeling Labs or Containerlab is the right choice. Most teams use one of each.

Is network emulation the same as network simulation?

No. Emulation runs real traffic, and with EVE-NG, GNS3 or Cisco Modeling Labs real vendor software, so your application experiences the network directly. Simulation models behavior instead of running real device software, which makes it better for research, teaching and large-scale design questions than for application testing.

Can I add latency and packet loss inside an EVE-NG or GNS3 lab?

Yes. A common approach is to add a Linux node running tc netem between two segments of the topology and apply delay, jitter or loss on that link. The routers and firewalls around it keep running real vendor software, so the application crosses a realistic path with controlled impairment.

Do I need my own servers to run a topology emulator for QA?

No. You can run EVE-NG, GNS3 or Cisco Modeling Labs on your own hardware, but each device image needs its own memory and CPU, and the emulator needs hardware virtualization. A hosted provider such as CloudMyLab runs the servers for you, on virtual machines or bare metal, and you upload your own images.